© Esther Johnson 2019© Esther Johnson 2019CAMPAIGN HISTORY

The campaign to preserve Alan Boyson’s ‘Three Ships’ is the vehicle that introduced Esther and Leigh to each other, and in turn helped them see what the murals mean to so many others.

The desire to collect and record social histories connected to the mural has evolved from the passion of the people of Hull just as much as Esther and Leigh’s love of the mural.

Below is a potted history of the campaign for Listing status to be granted for ‘Three Ships’, and to ensure the preservation of Alan Boyson’s other Hull murals ‘Fish’ and ‘Skyline’.

  • 2016

    Threat to Three Ships

    Hull Heritage Action Group (HHAG), Hull Civic Society (HCS), and The Twentieth Century Society (C20) all saw a potential threat to the ‘FISH‘ and ‘Three Ships‘ murals when BHS vacated the store in summer 2016 following the collapse of BHS.

    In the same year, Hull City Council (HCC) incorporated the ‘Albion Square Development’ into their City Plan. HHAG, HCS and C20 swiftly applied for Grade II Listing, however Listing was rejected and appeals were subsequently lodged in November 2016. Historic England stated that “it did not meet the required threshold for post-war public art.” In November 2016 HHAG launched a public petition calling for the murals to be listed. The petition did not gain momentum until the launch of a social media campaign in May 2017.

  • 2017

    2017

  • 2017

    Ambitions to Save Three Ships

    Hull City Council announced ambitions to save ‘Three Ships‘ during the 2017 Hull City of Culture. The council acquired the building from Manor Property Group, with a view to demolishing it in readiness to recruit a development partner. Surveys were undertaken on the ‘Fish’ and ‘Three Ships‘ murals to see how viable it was to protect them. Various possibilities were considered, ranging from integration into the new Albion Square development to relocating the murals elsewhere, as well as recreating a new artwork entirely.  HHAG issued a statement saying they, “welcomed Hull City Council’s recognition of the importance of the murals and are delighted that the Council are doing what they can to preserve them; saving them would be another fitting legacy to Hull 2017, and Absolutely Cultured.”

  • 2017-2019

    The Campaign Continues

    Hull Heritage Action Group, Hull Civic Society and The Twentieth Century Society continued to campaign for over three years for Grade II Listing of ‘Three Ships’, whilst awaiting an appeal decision from The Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS). HHAG, HCS and C20 felt that Listed status gave Alan Boyson’s exceptional art the recognition and protection it deserved and, also acknowledged the mural’s importance to the people of Hull and beyond. The murals were commissioned by the Co-operative Society in order to “unite the community through art” and acknowledge the importance of Hull as a port.  No expense was spared to build a replacement store after the original was bombed in 1941 during the infamous Hull Blitz, when the city was so badly scarred.

    In May 2017 the campaign established a dedicated social media presence through the @BHSMuralHull Twitter account to coordinate updates and public engagement and gain traction on the stalled petition which had not been widely promoted. The campaign and petition, standing at 200 signatures, quickly gathered widespread support and ultimately attracted more than 7,300 signatures, with Leigh Bird appearing on BBC Look North and BBC Radio Humberside within two weeks of the Twitter campaign launch.

    2017-2019

  • 2018

    Surveys, Reports and Planning Applications

    On 14 March 2018 Hull City Council undertook initial inspections of the ‘Three Ships’ mural to assess its structure and condition as redevelopment plans progressed.

    In June 2018 Leigh Bird undertook a review of Christopher Marsden’s publication, ‘Anything with Anything: An Introduction to the Art and Craft of Alan Boyson’ written in 2010 for the Journal of the Tiles & Architectural Ceramics Society (TACS). Marsden’s research contained a full catalogue of Boyson’s public works.

    The aim of the review was to ascertain which works had been lost in the intervening period and produce an analysis of what remained of each type of Boyson medium. The resulting 58-page document was presented to DCMS and Historic England in support of the case for Listing ‘Three Ships’, highlighting that both the ‘Three Ships’ and ‘Fish’ murals were two outstanding examples of what little remained of Alan Boyson’s public works.

    At the time, out of 47 public artworks created by Boyson, only 18 survived, and several were under threat.

    In September 2018, Hull City Council submitted an Outline Planning Application for the Albion Square development, whilst the DCMS appeal on Listing remained unresolved.

    Source: https://www.hullcc.gov.uk/padcbc/publicaccess-live/applicationDetails.do?activeTab=documents&keyVal=PE9MH5SO00300

  • 2018

    The Lost is Found

    On 29 November 2018, Hull City Council informed Hull Heritage Action Group that a third Alan Boyson mural had been identified within the building, strengthening the case for preserving the site’s artistic heritage.  The mural was found by Philip Andrew, Christopher Marsden and Esther Johnson as a result of interviewing Philip for ‘Ships in the Sky’.

    Source: https://www.hulldailymail.co.uk/news/third-forgotten-mural-could-still-2016389

    © The Andrew Estate

    2018

  • 2019

    Positive Survey Reports

    On 27 February 2019 Hull City Council announced its intention to repair and restore the internal Boyson murals and indicated that ‘Three Ships’ should also be retained, subject to further investigation.

    Source: https://news.hull.gov.uk/27/02/2019/council-intends-to-repair-internal-alan-boyson-mural-following-positive-surveyors-reports/

    On 3 April 2019 the public petition surpassed 6,000 signatures. Hull City Council’s planning committee approved outline redevelopment plans, subject to conditions intended to retain the ‘Three Ships’ mural if feasible, and preserve internal artworks.

    On 17 May 2019 coverage highlighted the role of Hull Heritage Action Group, Hull Civic Society and The Twentieth Century Society in leading the campaign to protect the murals since 2016.

    Source: https://tribunemag.co.uk/2019/05/hulls-ships-in-the-sky

  • 2019

    Asbestos in Three Ships, or not?

    On the 8 October 2019 Hull City Council detected the presence of asbestos in the building and research was undertaken to begin a costly exercise to remove and encapsulate it.  At that time it was ‘presumed’ that ‘Three Ships’ was contaminated by asbestos and the entire building – including the mural — ‘must be demolished‘.

    Sources: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-humber-49972611; https://news.hull.gov.uk/08/10/2019/council-desperately-disappointed-as-asbestos-survey-rules-out-retaining-three-ships-mural

    2019

  • 2019

    Hull City Council meeting

    Leigh Bird of Hull Heritage Action Group attended a meeting at Hull City Council on 17 October 2019 and presented an open letter with 171 signatures of eminent local and national arts and architecture professionals objecting to the ‘presumption’ that ‘Three Ships’ contained asbestos, and urging Councillors to take more time to get definitive proof before condemning the artwork to imminent demolition. Leigh also presented a petition which contained over 7,000 signatories in favour of preservation of the mosaic. The letter was put together in just under 24 hours by Leigh, Esther, Christopher Wilson and Lucy Elmes and was subsequently added to the following day with a further 67 late signatories, totalling 238 signatories in all. At the meeting the Councillors felt they had to agree with the proposal that demolition should proceed.

    Sources:
    BBC coverage: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-humber-50081091
    Twitter post containing the open letter: https://x.com/BhsMuralHull/status/1184728101466595328

  • 2019

    2019

  • 2019

    Following Listing

    Following Listing HHAG received offers of help from three nationally prominent experts in the fields of mosaic restoration and relocation and asbestos removal.  The three organisations offered their services to Hull City Council at no cost to undertake a joint preliminary investigation in order to see if ‘fresh eyes and advice’ could see an alternative way forward which might allow for preservation of the ‘Three Ships’ and not hold up development.  Over the next two years, various attempts were made for the advisors to visit the site. COVID restrictions was the cause of some delays, but in the end, HCC preferred to conduct their own investigations.

  • 2021

    2021

  • 2021

  • 2021

    Albion Square development plans

    On 20 October 2021, Hull City Council announced that the Albion Square development would undergo a further iteration. This included the removal of the Ice Arena from the development and the inclusion of an urban woodland. The announcement also confirmed that Alan Boyson’s ‘Three Ships’ could be saved.  Councillors speaking on BBC Radio Humberside also confirmed that ‘Three Ships’ was not contaminated with asbestos.

    2021

  • 2021

    Revised Albion Square development plans

    On 20 December 2021, an official go-ahead was given for the revised Albion Square development incorporating the ‘Three Ships’. An artists impression for the new building was released.

    Co-op News reported campaigners’ optimism after Hull City Council suggested a viable strategy had been identified to save and restore the mural. The article recognised the role of Hull Heritage Action Group and the successful Grade II Listing campaign.

    Source: Hopes for rescue of Hull’s iconic Three Ships Co-op mural

  • 2022

    Demolition announcement

    On 3 February 2022, there was the announcement of the imminent demolition of the former Co-op whilst retaining the two murals.  The Twentieth Century Society round-up the current plans used one of Esther’s images and referred to ‘Three Ships’ as ‘Ships in the Sky’, a testament to how the name of the project became synonymous with the artwork. This marked a major turning point in the campaign, shifting focus from preventing demolition to ensuring preservation and integration into future redevelopment plans.

    On 18 October 2022, Hull City Council’s Planning Committee approved updated Albion Square redevelopment proposals. The council confirmed demolition work was underway and continued referencing the intention to preserve the Grade II Listed ‘Three Ships’ mural within the redevelopment scheme.

    Source: Hull City Council redevelopment approval article

    2022

  • 2023-2024

    The Skyline mural is re-born

    The survival of the ‘Skyline’ sponge-print mural posed both a challenge and an opportunity. As the last known example of Boyson’s sponge-print technique, each remaining tile was carefully removed from the former Skyline Ballroom by Heritage Project Contracts in 2023. Out of the 658 original tiles, 396 were missing and had to be painstakingly re-created by hand.

    Working with Hull City Council and Vinci Construction, a specialist team at Craven Dunnill (Jackfield) Ltd. cleaned up the existing tiles, replicated the missing patterns, undertaking an extensive programme of colour trials and sponge-print testing to ensure that the new tiles matched Boyson’s original artistic intent. In this way, the reinstated mural remains true both to the surviving tiles and to Boyson’s vision.  Hull Heritage Action Group were consulted at several stages during the testing and evaluation process and, Esther was invited to document the installation process for ‘Ships in the Sky’.

    Esther wrote an article for The Twentieth Century Society magazine about Boyson’s sponge-print tiles, published in May 2026.

  • 2025

    Next redevelopment phase announced

    On 18 December 2025, Hull City Council announced the next stage of the Albion Square redevelopment. The ‘Three Ships’ mural continued to feature prominently in regeneration communications, confirming its ongoing importance within the redevelopment narrative and city identity.

    Source: Council starts next phase in redevelopment of Albion Square

    2025

  • 2026

    Formal bids invited for Albion Square development

    On 22 January 2026, Hull City Council formally began procurement for a lead development partner for Albion Square. The announcement again referenced the ‘Three Ships’ mural as part of the site’s heritage significance.

    Source: Formal bids for Albion Square lead development partner welcome

  • 2026

    Demolition approval confirmed

    On 1 May 2026, Hull City Council confirmed that permission had been granted for demolition of the former Co-op/BHS building. Coverage continued to emphasise that the Grade II Listed ‘Three Ships’ mural would be protected through the process.

    Source: BHS building demolition approved

    Related BBC East Yorkshire social coverage: https://www.facebook.com/BBCEastYorkshire/posts/a-steel-structure-will-be-built-to-protect-the-grade-ii-listed-three-ships-mural/1328429842782127/

    2026